Warning: Sort of Spoiler Alert... If you haven't seen Knocked Up yet, you might want to vaminos. But I'm not giving away the big surprise ending or anything.
Okay. I'll start by saying that I ROTFLOL'd during Knocked Up. Judd Apatow's a funny dude. There's no question about it.
But WTFuck was up with the weird pro-life message?
Look at Alison's situation. Early 20's, about to get her own gig as a TV personality, gets preggered by some random d-bag she doesn't know. In the real world, that would be an automatic abortion situation. Seriously.
As my friend Melanie put it, "it would have been a short movie if it was pro choice". Touche. But what bothered me was the way they portrayed the pro-choice characters in the film as monsters, and the way they treat abortion - quite literally - as a dirty word. "Schmaschmortion"?!?!? Are you kidding me?
I think this actually takes away from the film... My "willingness to suspend my disbelief" was taking serious punches when the only two voices of reason were the wicked mother, who tells Alison that she can "take care of it" now and have a "real baby" later, and Ben's dumb, fat, stoner friend who "won't say the A word".
And I don't even mean to say "voice of reason" because abortion was the right choice. They were the voice of reason, because schmaschmortion is, indeed, a second, reasonable option, and to rule it out so automatically is unreasonable. To treat it as an impossibility, I think, was an insult to the viewer.
All the movie needed was an impetus for Alison to want the baby. Maybe seeing her sister's adorable kids playing outside... I don't know... Anything more than having the baby simply because it's what ya do.
There are ways this movie could have worked without glossing over abortion as a silly non-option.
If you think I'm being paranoid liberaljew, check out the Evangelical Outpost review. They give it a "pat on the back".
Also, BTW, did anyone else notice the subliminal message in the doctor's office waiting room?




